Author: Amanda Flower
Series: An Emily Dickinson Mystery (Book 3)
Publication: Berkley (February 25, 2025)
Description: When a blaze takes both a neighbor’s home and his life, Emily Dickinson and her maid Willa have a burning desire to crack the case in this new historical mystery from Agatha Award–winning author Amanda Flower.
Amherst, 1857. The Dickinson family braves one of the worst winters in New England’s history. Trains are snowbound and boats are frozen in the harbor. Emily Dickinson and her maid, Willa Noble, have never witnessed anything like it. As Amherst families attempt to keep their homes warm, fears of fire abound.
These worries prove not to be unfounded as a blaze breaks out just down the street from the Dickinson in Kelley Square, the Irish community in Amherst, and a young couple is killed, leaving behind their young child. Their deaths appear to be a tragic accident, but Emily finds herself harboring suspicions there may be more to the fire than meets the eye. Emily and Willa must withstand the frigid temperatures and discover a killer lurking among the deadly frost.
My Thoughts: During a very cold January 1857 in Amherst, Emily Dickinson and her loyal maid Willa Noble investigate the deaths of two Irish immigrants who left an 8-year-old daughter behind when they died in a fire.
Their investigations take them into the drawing rooms of Amherst's high society. Many of the women had employed the dead woman as a seamstress and the dead man worked at the college as a janitor. He also assisted one of the professors with his botanical experiments.
Tensions rise as the temperatures plummet. Suffragist Lucy Stone is stranded in town and staying with the president of Amherst College's wife who has a childhood friend. She has strong opinions about the roles and rights of women and offers lectures.
Meanwhile, two competing organizations are working to provide for the mainly Irish Poor who are running out of food and fuel.
Willa is the narrator, and, in this episode, we learn about a tough decision she has to make about her future. Does she love her policeman boyfriend enough to marry him? And can they make a home and family with the young orphan?
This was another engaging historical mystery. I like Emily's portrayal as a woman who doesn't concern herself with social rules and who often goes off into her own mind when a poem comes to her. I like that Willa collects the bits of poems that Emily discards.